HeadshotKiwi vs ProPhotosAI: if you don’t know which of the two AI headshot generators to choose, we’re here to help.
We have compared the two tools side by side, and both products have strong pros and cons. So, what was the determining factor that helped us find the winner? The overall quality of the AI-generated headshots!
Let’s take a closer look at the HeadshotKiwi vs ProPhotosAI debate, starting with the differences in the generating process.
Generating Headshots With HeadshotKiwi vs ProPhotosAI
ProPhotosAI homepage.
The first immediate difference between the generating processes of HeadshotKiwi and ProPhotosAI is how much you can do for free with each tool. With Kiwi, users can test the headshot creation process without paying (even though a subscription is required to download the headshots); with ProPhotosAI, you need to buy a premium even before uploading the selfies to the website!
Anyone can get a professional AI headshot on HeadshotKiwi in five simple steps, and ProPhotosAI is nearly as simple. You just need to upload 10-20 selfies, pick a style, review the photos, and download the final headshots. The selfie instructions are the same for both products (learn more about selfies for AI headshots in this step-by-step guide).
Offering up to 40 outfits and backgrounds (the HeadshotKiwi plans offer up to 25), ProPhotosAI is a customization beast; it also has the advantage of being more literal in its approach to diverse industry sectors, as exemplified by these hilarious headshots:
ProPhotosAI lets you generate industry-specific headshots.
On the other hand, ProPhotosAI’s “pay first, see how it works later” system can be extremely inconvenient, especially for beginners. Additionally, it’s worth mentioning that, while HeadshotKiwi doesn’t directly tackle jobs such as “Astronaut” and “Farmer”, it does let you choose different styles, each fitting specific job niches.
| HeadshotKiwi | ProPhotosAI | |
|---|---|---|
| Selfies required | 13 | 10-20 |
| Backgrounds + outfits | 5-25 | 8-40 |
| Time to generate the headshots | 30-45 minutes | 30-90 minutes |
HeadshotKiwi vs ProPhotosAI: Which One is Cheaper?
ProPhotosAI’s plans cost, on average, $10 more than HeadshotKiwi’s plans.
If saving money is your top priority, HeadshotKiwi is the wisest choice. While both products have advantages and disadvantages in their generating processes, there’s no doubt that Kiwi beats ProPhotosAI in terms of affordability.
Here’s how the three plans of HeadshotKiwi and ProPhotosAI compare:
| HeadshotKiwi | ProPhotosAI | |
|---|---|---|
| Starter plan | $29 for 40 headshots | $39 for 40 headshots |
| Mid-level plan | $39 for 120 headshots | $49 for 100 headshots |
| Executive plan | $59 for 250 headshots | $59 for 250 headshots |
In addition to helping you save $10 in the Starter and mid-level plans, HeadshotKiwi delivers more headshots per plan. This is the average cost per headshot of HeadshotKiwi vs ProPhotosAI:
| HeadshotKiwi | ProPhotosAI | |
|---|---|---|
| Starter plans | $0.73 | $0.98 |
| Mid-level plans | $0.33 | $0.49 |
| Executive plans | $0.24 | $0.30 |
All things considered, ProPhotosAI is more expensive than HeadshotKiwi, especially if you’re considering a Starter plan. At almost $1 per AI headshot, ProPhotosAI is one of the costlier AI headshot generators around — even HeadshotPro costs less than $0.75 per headshot!
Paying the extra cost is only worthwhile if you’re looking for an AI background remover tool, as the ProPhotosAI mid-level and executive plans include this feature as an add-on.
Reviewing HeadshotKiwi vs ProPhotosAI Headshots
At this point, HeadshotKiwi and ProPhotosAI are tied: Kiwi is more affordable and better for free users, whereas ProPhotosAI features a larger selection of backgrounds and a useful AI background remover. So, it’s time to look at the essential element of any AI headshot product: the quality of the images generated!
First, it’s important to recognize that both HeadshotKiwi and ProPhotosAI can produce stunning AI headshots to help you boost job applications and networking. However, when we start focusing on the details, HeadshotKiwi comes on top.
Consider the following examples, published on ProPhotosAI’s homepage:
Five headshots generated by ProPhotosAI.
The attire of the AI doctor looks great, but the background is far from ideal. Counting from the left, the second subject is impressively realistic, but the man in the middle shows some clear signs of AI, particularly in the beard. Headshot number four is convincing, but the outfit is so wonky that the man’s head looks almost Photoshopped into the image…
Now, compare the ProPhotosAI examples with some of the AI headshots generated by HeadshotKiwi:
Four headshots generated by HeadshotKiwi.
Why do Kiwi’s AI headshots look so much better? For one, the AI system interprets and generates lighting more naturally; this causes Kiwi’s headshots to feel real and lively, whereas ProPhotosAI’s images look flat and grey. Additionally, Kiwi generates natural and empathetic expressions better than ProPhotosAI does. These are vital for psychologically powerful headshots.
HeadshotKiwi vs ProPhotosAI: Everything You Need to Know
HeadshotKiwi pricing: get it now for only $29 a month!
In sum, we believe that:
- HeadshotKiwi is ultimately better than ProPhotosAI because it’s superior at generating realistic and attractive AI headshots.
However, this doesn’t mean HeadshotKiwi beats ProPhotosAI in every single parameter. This is what ProPhotosAI does better:
- More backgrounds and outfits to choose from;
- Job-specific generating options;
- AI background remover feature as an extra;
- More established in the market (at the time of writing, ProPhotosAI claims to have generated over 12 million AI headshots, considerably more than HeadshotKiwi’s 523k headshots).
So, if your number-one priority is to create AI headshots that fully reflect your job, especially in blue-collar professions, maybe ProPhotosAI isn’t such a bad choice. However, keep in mind that the product has several drawbacks when compared to HeadshotKiwi!
After all, this is what HeadshotKiwi does better:
- Cheaper cost per headshot on every plan;
- Users can test the generating process without paying (on ProPhotosAI, paying for a premium is the necessary first step);
- Specific offers for teams (ProPhotosAI only covers individual and enterprise options, missing middle-term plans);
- The AI headshots simply look better, especially due to their realistic lighting and attractive expressions.
Considering that, like ProPhotosAI, Kiwi also covers several niches (albeit with a less specific approach), our conviction is that HeadshotKiwi’s superior headshots are too big an advantage to justify choosing ProPhotosAI.
For more alternatives to HeadshotKiwi and ProPhotosAI, please check our list of the best AI headshot generators.
